How to practise dermatologic surgery viva questions

A dermatologic surgery viva tests whether you can turn a clinical problem into a safe, reasoned plan and explain it clearly. Practise speaking through the decision, not reciting a list of procedures. For each case, make your answer easy to follow: clarify the problem, state your priorities, explain the proposed procedure, address risk and consent, then cover aftercare and complications.

There is no single international dermatologic surgery viva blueprint. The stations below are practice scenarios, not a claim about a particular examination’s format or marking scheme. Adapt decisions to the patient, the lesion, local guidance and your level of competence. When a question depends on a local guideline—such as margins, anticoagulation policy or antibiotic prophylaxis—say so and explain what you would check.

In practice, give the examiner your headline plan first. Then justify it. If you are uncertain, state what information you need and how it could change your plan. Avoid saying only that you would “refer” or “follow protocol”: name the immediate safety issue and the next step.

A MySummaries examiner strip for this subject can keep the practice priorities visible. These are the platform’s practice emphases, not official criteria for an examination.

ExaminerDermatologic Surgery practice examiner
Indication and procedural planningAnatomy and patient safetyComplications and aftercare

Build a station routine before you start

Use the same sequence across cases so that you do not forget consent, haemostasis or follow-up when the technical part becomes difficult.

  1. Define the problem. Summarise the lesion or wound, its site and the relevant history. Ask about prior treatment, allergies, medicines, bleeding history, immune status, healing problems and the patient’s priorities.
  2. Choose the next step. Explain whether you need more information, a biopsy, excision, referral or another approach. Match the procedure to the diagnostic question and the site. Do not promise a cosmetic or oncological outcome you cannot guarantee.
  3. Plan the procedure. Describe positioning, marking, anaesthesia, asepsis, incision or excision, specimen handling, haemostasis and closure. Name the structures or functional risks that matter at that site.
  4. Explain consent and safety. Discuss material risks in plain language, alternatives, scar placement, expected recovery and the possibility of further treatment. Check capacity and understanding; answer questions without rushing the decision.
  5. Close the loop. State what happens to the specimen, how results are communicated, when review is needed and what symptoms should prompt earlier contact.

A useful spoken answer is specific but not overconfident. For example: “I would confirm the diagnosis and the patient’s priorities, then choose a procedure that gives an adequate specimen while protecting function at this site. I would check the relevant local guidance before setting the definitive margin.” That is stronger than giving a number from memory when the applicable guideline is uncertain.

The MySummaries Oral tab can turn those themes into short stations to rehearse. One station is left unsat so the practice set includes a prompt you have not yet attempted.

StationAttemptsBestAvg
Changing pigmented lesionA patient has a changing pigmented lesion on the upper arm. Talk me through your assessment and biopsy plan.37871
Repair after excisionYou have excised a skin tumour on the cheek. How will you choose and perform a suitable repair?28174
Bleeding after surgeryA patient calls several hours after a skin excision because the dressing is soaked with blood. What will you do?16969
Possible wound infectionOn review, a surgical wound is painful and erythematous. How will you assess and manage it?0——

Station 1: changing pigmented lesion

This station tests whether you distinguish diagnostic sampling from definitive treatment, and whether your plan protects future management. Avoid jumping straight to a wide excision before establishing the diagnosis. A suspected melanoma commonly calls for a complete, full-thickness diagnostic excision with a narrow clinical margin when feasible; the precise approach should follow current local guidance and the lesion’s site and size. If complete excision is impractical or would cause significant functional or cosmetic harm, explain why you would discuss the case with an appropriate specialist rather than improvise a partial sample.

In the viva, cover history and examination, the reason for the biopsy, specimen orientation or labelling where relevant, and follow-up of the histology. Your answer should make clear that a benign-looking or reassuring initial impression does not replace a reliable result-tracking system.

A MySummaries oral attempt on this case might be marked against platform practice criteria. The scores below represent a candidate mid-preparation, not an examination result.

Oral — Changing pigmented lesionMarked

Examiner

A 46-year-old has a pigmented lesion on the upper arm that has enlarged and changed colour over six months. Talk me through your assessment and biopsy plan.

2:283:00Mark answer
76%Changing pigmented lesion — marked76/100 · Developing · 2:28 spoken of 3:00
Clinical reasoning and prioritisation15/20

You recognised change over time as concerning and made diagnosis the priority.

ImproveState that you would assess the lesion and relevant history before selecting a biopsy method.

Procedure choice and planning14/20

You proposed excision but did not explain the diagnostic purpose or specimen depth.

ImproveDescribe a complete, full-thickness diagnostic excision with a narrow margin when feasible, subject to local guidance and site constraints.

Safety, consent and communication16/20

You mentioned consent and scarring but omitted important history and patient priorities.

ImproveAsk about medicines, allergies, bleeding history and expectations; discuss alternatives and material risks.

Follow-up and continuity17/20

You planned to review the result, which closes an important safety gap.

ImproveSpecify how you will track the histology, communicate it and arrange next steps if it is concerning.

A strong answerI would ask about the lesion’s evolution, symptoms, previous treatment and relevant personal or family history, and examine and document it carefully. Change in size and colour makes a reliable diagnosis important, so I would choose a biopsy method that provides suitable full-thickness tissue; for a suspected melanoma, complete diagnostic excision with a narrow margin is used when feasible, following local guidance. I would consider the site, lesion size and functional or cosmetic consequences, and seek specialist advice if complete excision is not appropriate in this setting. I would explain scar, bleeding, infection, possible further surgery and alternatives, then obtain informed consent. I would label and send the specimen correctly, track the histology, communicate the result and arrange definitive management if indicated.

That is a MySummaries station, filled with dermatologic surgery material. Yours is written from your own notes. Start free

The key improvement is to connect the procedure to the diagnostic question and the result pathway. A biopsy is not complete from a safety perspective until somebody is responsible for reviewing and communicating the report.

Station 2: repair after excision

A repair station is about choosing a closure that suits the defect, not showing off a named flap. Start by describing the defect: site, dimensions, depth, tension, tissue laxity and proximity to free margins or important structures. Consider the direction of relaxed skin tension lines and the effect of closure on function. Then compare options such as direct closure, a local flap, a graft or healing by secondary intention, explaining why the simplest suitable option may be safest.

If you choose a flap, explain its design in relation to the defect, its blood supply, the direction of movement and how you will avoid excessive tension or distortion. Identify nearby structures at risk. Describe careful haemostasis and layered closure where appropriate, without claiming that one design fits every cheek, nose or eyelid defect. If the defect is complex or outside your competence, say when you would seek help.

The next MySummaries oral case records how a candidate explains reconstruction and checks function, rather than testing one universal flap recipe.

Oral — Repair after excisionMarked

Examiner

A 1.2 cm skin defect remains on the cheek after excision of a lesion. Explain how you would assess the defect and choose a repair.

2:363:00Mark answer
82%Repair after excision — marked82/100 · Good progress · 2:36 spoken of 3:00
Assessment of defect and site18/20

You considered size and laxity but did not mention nearby free margins or functional distortion.

ImproveDescribe the defect’s depth, tension and relationship to the eyelid, nose and mouth before choosing a repair.

Reasoned choice of reconstruction17/20

You compared direct closure and a local flap, giving a defensible basis for the choice.

ImproveExplain why grafting or secondary intention may or may not suit this specific defect.

Technical safety16/20

You mentioned haemostasis but left the flap’s blood supply and tension management implicit.

ImproveName the vascular basis of the chosen flap and explain how you would avoid a tight closure.

Consent and aftercare15/20

You discussed scarring but omitted wound care and review arrangements.

ImproveCover likely scar, risks, instructions, suture review or removal as appropriate, and when to seek help.

A strong answerI would assess the defect’s dimensions, depth, tissue laxity and tension, and its relationship to the eyelid, nose, mouth and other structures. I would discuss the patient’s priorities and compare direct closure, a local flap, a graft or secondary intention, choosing the simplest option that preserves function and gives a reasonable result. If a local flap is appropriate, I would plan its movement and blood supply, align it with local skin lines where possible and avoid distortion or excessive tension. I would check haemostasis, close appropriately and confirm that nearby structures and function are satisfactory. Beforehand, I would explain scar, bleeding, infection, possible flap or graft compromise and alternatives, then give clear wound-care and follow-up advice.

A strong answer makes the reasoning visible: what you observed, which options you considered and why your chosen repair fits this defect. If the examiner changes the defect’s position or size, revisit the plan rather than repeating the same flap answer.

Station 3: bleeding after surgery

For a patient reporting postoperative bleeding, put immediate safety before a detailed discussion of technique. Establish whether bleeding is ongoing, how much blood has been lost, whether the patient feels faint or unwell, and whether there are symptoms suggesting a more serious problem. Ask the patient to apply firm, continuous pressure with clean material while you arrange assessment; advise urgent emergency care if bleeding is severe, the patient is unstable or the situation cannot be controlled safely. Do not tell a patient to stop prescribed anticoagulants independently.

At assessment, review the procedure, wound, medicines and relevant bleeding history. If the patient is stable and bleeding is local, use appropriate direct measures and escalate if it persists or the source is uncertain. Explain that management depends on the site, severity, patient factors and local resources. Your answer should also include documentation, clear return precautions and a review plan.

The third MySummaries oral recording focuses on triage, safe immediate advice and the limits of remote assessment.

Oral — Bleeding after surgeryMarked

Examiner

A patient calls several hours after an excision on the scalp. The dressing is soaked with blood. Talk me through your immediate advice and assessment.

2:193:00Mark answer
71%Bleeding after surgery — marked71/100 · Needs another attempt · 2:19 spoken of 3:00
Triage and immediate safety15/20

You advised pressure, but did not first screen for severe bleeding or symptoms of instability.

ImproveAsk whether bleeding is ongoing and check for faintness, collapse or other signs requiring emergency assessment.

Practical first response16/20

You gave a useful instruction to apply pressure but did not specify continuous pressure or a clear escalation threshold.

ImproveAdvise firm, continuous pressure with clean material and urgent assessment if bleeding is severe or not controlled.

Risk review and escalation13/20

You mentioned medication but did not warn against stopping anticoagulants without medical advice.

ImproveReview medicines and bleeding history; do not recommend unsupervised interruption of prescribed anticoagulation.

Communication and follow-up14/20

You planned review but omitted documentation and return precautions.

ImproveGive explicit instructions for urgent help, document advice and ensure a review plan.

A strong answerI would first establish whether the bleeding is still active and ask about the amount, faintness, collapse or other signs that the patient may be unwell. If bleeding is severe, the patient is unstable or they cannot manage safely, I would direct them to emergency care and arrange urgent assessment. If they are stable, I would advise firm, continuous pressure over the site with clean material while arranging prompt review; repeated checking can interrupt pressure. I would assess the wound, the procedure, medicines and bleeding history, and manage the source according to the findings and local resources, escalating if it persists or is unclear. I would not tell them to stop prescribed anticoagulants on their own, and I would document the advice, explain return precautions and confirm follow-up.

The common omission here is a precise escalation plan. “Apply pressure and come in if worried” leaves the patient to decide what counts as dangerous. Name the symptoms or situation that requires urgent assessment, and be clear about what to do now.

Review the recording, not just the score

After each attempt, listen for missing actions as well as incorrect facts. Did you establish the patient’s priorities? Did you explain why your procedure fits the problem? Did you name risks that matter at that site? Did you state who follows the histology or wound? A high-level answer is not necessarily a long one; it is ordered and complete enough for the case.

One useful transcript review is to mark a sentence as either a knowledge gap or a detail that was too vague. For example, “I would stop the bleeding” names an aim but not a safe plan. Replace it with the sequence you would actually use: assess severity, advise continuous pressure if appropriate, arrange urgent assessment when indicated, and review medicines without changing them independently.

The MySummaries transcript view can isolate the phrase that cost a mark and suggest wording to practise next time.

Transcript

I would ask if the bleeding is still active and whether they feel faint or unwell. I would tell them to press on it and come in if it carries on. I would also check their medicines and the wound. If they take an anticoagulant, I would tell them to miss the next dose.

not enough detail
I would tell them to press on it and come in if it carries on.

The advice does not say to use firm continuous pressure or identify when the patient needs urgent emergency assessment. The final sentence also makes a medication change without clinical review.

Say: Advise firm, continuous pressure with clean material while arranging assessment if they are stable; direct severe or uncontrolled bleeding or signs of instability to urgent emergency care. Review anticoagulants, but do not advise stopping a prescribed medicine without appropriate medical assessment.

Finish practice by choosing one correction for the next attempt, not by rewriting the whole answer. If you lost marks for omitting result tracking, make that your opening checklist item next time. If your answer was safe but vague, practise naming the action and the reason in one sentence.

How MySummaries helps

MySummaries builds a revision board from your own dermatologic surgery notes and can turn it into recorded viva stations, with feedback on the spoken answer and wording to revisit. Use it to rehearse a changing lesion, repair planning or postoperative bleeding against the guidance you study from, then review the points you repeatedly miss. Open MySummaries.