How to practise Equity and Trusts viva questions
Equity and Trusts vivas test more than whether you can recall a definition. You need to identify the equitable issue in a fact pattern, state the governing principle, apply it to the facts and explain the likely remedy. An examiner may then change one fact or challenge an assumption in your answer. Your task is to show a line of reasoning, not to recite a paragraph of notes.
There is no single international syllabus or universal marking scheme for an Equity and Trusts viva. The principles and examples below use familiar common-law concepts, but rules, terminology and remedies differ between jurisdictions. Check your course materials and the relevant legislation and cases for your jurisdiction. In particular, be ready to distinguish a rule stated in your local law from a broader equitable idea.
A useful answer has four moves:
- Identify the issue. Name the trust, duty, equitable doctrine or remedy raised by the facts.
- State the test. Give the relevant rule accurately, including any threshold or qualification you know.
- Apply it. Tie each element to a fact; identify missing facts where necessary.
- Conclude with care. Say what follows on the facts, what remedy may be available and what could change the result.
Practise aloud in short, complete sentences. If you do not know a detail, say what you would need to establish rather than filling the gap with a guess. A useful follow-up is: “That conclusion depends on whether the recipient had the required knowledge; I would need to establish what they knew and when.”
A viva board on this topic can keep the doctrines and the facts you need to recall in one place. MySummaries builds the board from your own course material; a board on this topic ends up looking like this:
The emphases shown here are practice prompts, not official criteria for any particular university or professional examination. Make a separate note of the cases, statutory provisions and terminology your own course expects.
Build a station answer, not a speech
For each doctrine, prepare a compact map rather than a memorised script: the rule, its elements, one authority your course uses, the application questions, and the remedies or defences that may follow. A map makes it easier to respond when the examiner changes a fact. For example, if a question about a fiduciary opportunity changes from “the principal refused it” to “the principal was never told”, that may matter to informed consent, but it does not remove the need to analyse the fiduciary’s duty and any profit obtained.
Use signposting so the examiner can follow you: “The first issue is whether a trust was created. I will address intention, subject matter and objects, then consider constitution.” This does not require a long introduction. Move promptly to the test and the facts.
A set of stations drafted from a candidate’s own notes might look like this. The attempts column is useful for choosing what to rehearse next; an unattempted station is a prompt to practise it aloud.
Station one: the informal declaration
This station tests whether you can separate the requirements for an express trust from the separate question of whether trust property has been effectively transferred. In the practice recording, the platform rubric awards credit for issue spotting, accurate legal reasoning, application and a suitably qualified conclusion. That rubric is for practice, not a universal viva scheme.
Examiner
A testator leaves £50,000 to a friend ‘to share among my old friends’. Is there an express trust? Explain what further facts you would need.
Identifies the three certainties and recognises that ‘old friends’ raises a question about certainty of objects.
ImproveState clearly that intention and subject matter also need to be tested, rather than assuming them from the amount and wording.
Explains that the trust property and beneficiaries must be sufficiently certain; uses the familiar three-certainties framework.
ImproveDistinguish uncertainty in the class of beneficiaries from difficulty proving whether a particular person falls within it.
Notices that ‘old friends’ may not provide a workable class, but does not ask about the testator’s usage or evidence.
ImproveExplain what evidence could clarify the expression and why the answer depends on the trust’s construction and applicable test.
Reaches a cautious conclusion but omits the consequence if the objects are too uncertain.
ImproveSay that if the trust fails for uncertainty, the property’s destination depends on the will’s construction and local succession law.
A strong answerI would first test the three certainties: intention, subject matter and objects. The £50,000 identifies the subject matter, but the wording ‘to share among my old friends’ raises a substantial question about who qualifies and whether the trustee can apply a workable test. I would examine the will as a whole and admissible context under the rules of the relevant jurisdiction; I would not assume that a socially familiar phrase defines a legally certain class. I would also distinguish uncertainty about the class from a factual dispute about whether one person belongs to it. If the objects are too uncertain, the express trust may fail, and the will and local succession rules determine where the fund goes.
That is a MySummaries station, filled with equity and trusts material. Yours is written from your own notes. Start free
The model answer avoids declaring that “old friends” is automatically invalid. It identifies the difficult element, explains what evidence and legal construction matter, and does not invent a destination for the fund. In a real viva, the examiner may follow up with a more precise class, such as named beneficiaries, or ask whether a discretionary trust and a fixed trust use the same test. Answer that narrower question directly, and use the test taught in your jurisdiction.
One frequent loss of clarity is jumping from “the words are uncertain” to “the trust fails” without showing which certainty is in issue. The transcript below demonstrates how to make that step more precise.
The three certainties are intention, subject matter and objects. The phrase ‘old friends’ is uncertain, so the trust fails. I would want to know how the testator used that phrase and what evidence is admissible. If it fails, the money goes back to the estate.
The phrase ‘old friends’ is uncertain, so the trust fails.
This states a conclusion without explaining the applicable test or distinguishing uncertainty in the class from a factual question about membership. It also assumes the destination of the fund without construing the will or checking local law.
Say: Say which certainty is challenged, identify the construction and evidence questions, then qualify the consequence: ‘If the objects are too uncertain, the trust may fail; the will and applicable succession rules determine the fund’s destination.’Station two: the undisclosed opportunity
This station tests fiduciary loyalty and the difference between identifying a breach and selecting a remedy. Do not start by asking only whether the trust lost money: a fiduciary may be required to account for an unauthorised profit even where the principal cannot show a corresponding loss. The precise duty and available remedies depend on the relationship and the law applied.
Examiner
While administering a trust, a trustee learns of a profitable business opportunity and takes it personally without telling the beneficiaries. Explain the possible breach and remedies.
Recognises the fiduciary’s duty of loyalty and the conflict between personal gain and proper administration.
ImproveExplain that the precise scope of the duty depends on the trustee’s role and the opportunity’s connection to the trust.
Identifies that disclosure and fully informed consent may matter; applies the absence of disclosure to the facts.
ImproveAvoid treating silence by beneficiaries as consent; identify who had authority to consent and what information they needed.
Mentions an account of profits and considers whether a proprietary remedy may be relevant.
ImproveSeparate the personal account from a claim to specific property, which requires its own legal basis and tracing analysis.
Uses a relevant fiduciary principle but does not connect authority carefully to the factual relationship.
ImproveUse an authority prescribed by your course and explain the proposition it supports; qualify for local statutory or doctrinal differences.
A strong answerThe first question is whether the trustee was acting in a fiduciary capacity in relation to this opportunity. If the opportunity arose through the administration of the trust, taking it personally without disclosure creates a serious conflict and unauthorised-profit issue. The trustee would need properly informed consent from someone with authority to give it; the fact that no loss to the trust is proved does not by itself answer an account-of-profits claim. A personal account may be available, subject to the applicable law and any allowance recognised for the trustee’s work. A proprietary claim to the opportunity or its proceeds is a separate question: I would identify its legal basis and consider whether the property can be traced.
In your own answer, name an authority only when you can explain what it contributes. For example, common-law courses often discuss Keech v Sandford in relation to a trustee’s unauthorised profit, and Boardman v Phipps when considering fiduciary profit and possible allowances. Check how your jurisdiction treats those cases and the particular proposition your course draws from them. Do not use a case name as a substitute for applying the facts.
A helpful examiner follow-up is: “What if the beneficiaries would have rejected the opportunity?” Address consent and the fiduciary’s duty, then distinguish that point from the remedy. Do not assume that the principal’s inability or unwillingness to take the opportunity automatically authorises the fiduciary to do so.
Station three: the misapplied fund
This station brings together the trustee’s primary breach, the recipient’s position and tracing. A careful answer keeps those questions separate. A transfer by a trustee may be a breach even if the recipient is innocent; personal liability against the recipient usually requires its own legal basis and is not established simply by showing that trust money reached them.
Examiner
A trustee transfers £20,000 of trust money to a relative, who says they did not know it was trust property. The relative spends £5,000 and uses the rest to buy shares. Analyse the possible claims.
Identifies the trustee’s breach separately from possible claims against the recipient.
ImproveState the primary claim against the trustee first, including the need to establish breach and the relevant loss or restoration measure.
Recognises that the relative’s knowledge matters, but describes the test too generally.
ImproveUse the recipient-liability terminology and elements adopted in your jurisdiction; do not infer knowledge merely from family relationship.
Notices that some money has been spent and some converted into shares.
ImproveExplain that tracing identifies value into substitutes; assess the shares separately and do not assume a personal claim makes every asset recoverable.
Concludes that the beneficiaries may pursue the remaining value but omits local differences and defences.
ImproveQualify the proprietary and personal remedies, and ask whether the recipient gave value, still retains value, or has a relevant defence.
A strong answerThe trustee’s unauthorised transfer is the first issue: the beneficiaries may seek a personal remedy against the trustee for breach, subject to the applicable measure of restoration or loss. The relative’s liability is a separate question. I would identify the recipient-liability doctrine and apply the knowledge and other elements recognised by the relevant jurisdiction; family relationship alone does not prove them. For proprietary recovery, I would trace the £15,000 used to buy shares and consider whether the shares, or a proportionate interest in them, can be claimed under local rules. The £5,000 already spent may no longer be identifiable in an asset, although a personal claim may still be possible if its elements are made out. I would ask what the relative knew, whether any value was given, and what remains before reaching a conclusion.
The scenario intentionally leaves facts open. “I need to know whether the relative gave value” is a useful answer if you explain why it matters; it is not a substitute for stating the possible claim. Depending on the course and jurisdiction, the examiner may expect discussion of knowing receipt, dishonest assistance, tracing, a proprietary claim or a personal claim against the trustee. These are not interchangeable labels. State the route you are analysing and its requirements, and check the relevant local authorities before relying on a particular test.
Review recordings with a repeatable method
After each attempt, review more than the overall score. Listen for where you stated a rule without applying it, where you reached a conclusion without considering a qualification, and where you used a remedy label without explaining its basis. Turn each repeated gap into one short prompt, such as “recipient’s knowledge: identify the local test” or “account of profits versus proprietary claim”. Rehearse the revised answer in a fresh fact pattern, rather than repeating the same script word for word.
A useful weekly routine is three short sessions: one to recall a doctrine without notes, one to answer a changed fact pattern aloud, and one to review recordings and repair the weakest point. Keep each answer within a set practice time, but do not treat the sample station targets here as official timings. Follow your course’s instructions for the actual assessment.
The spoken debrief can make one improvement easier to remember. This example draws attention to a distinction that often gets lost in a fast answer.
You separated the trustee’s breach from the recipient’s possible liability; now state the local knowledge test before concluding that a personal claim is available.
How MySummaries helps
MySummaries turns your own Equity and Trusts notes into a revision board, then uses that material to create viva stations, record spoken answers and mark them against a practice rubric. You can review where your reasoning was incomplete, return to the relevant notes and practise a new answer. Start with your own course material at portal.mysummaries.app.