How to practise medical genetics viva questions

Medical genetics is a broad subject, not one internationally standardised viva. The format, syllabus and assessment criteria depend on the course or professional examination you are preparing for. Check the relevant institution’s official guidance for those details. The practice stations here test transferable skills: explaining genetic evidence, reasoning through inheritance, and communicating what a test result can and cannot show.

In a viva, aim to make your reasoning audible. Start with the issue in the case, state what information you would check, explain the limits of what is known, then give a safe and proportionate next step. If you do not know a detail, say what you would verify rather than guessing. Avoid turning a possible explanation into a diagnosis before the evidence supports it.

For each station below, answer aloud before reading the model. Treat the three-minute target as a practice limit, not a claim about any particular exam. The scores and criteria shown in the examples are practice feedback, not official examination marking schemes.

Set up a small station circuit

Practise stations drawn from the same revision board so that you have to retrieve facts and apply them in context. A useful circuit covers a molecular result, a family history, and a test with important limitations. Add a fourth station on consent or a different inheritance mechanism when you repeat the circuit.

The examiner strip below is a generic practice persona, not an exam body’s specification. Its emphasis is on clear reasoning, accurate genetic concepts and responsible communication. A station opener should give you enough to begin, but you should identify missing details instead of silently filling them in.

A MySummaries examiner strip for a general medical genetics practice circuit looks like this:

ExaminerMedical Genetics viva practice
Interpret evidence and state its limitationsExplain inheritance and recurrence risk clearlyCommunicate uncertainty and appropriate next steps

The station table turns a topic board into short, spoken tasks. Attempts and scores are practice history, not predicted exam results. For an unfamiliar case, make the opening move explicit: clarify the question, summarise the relevant facts, and identify what information would change your answer.

A MySummaries station list for this circuit could look like this:

StationAttemptsBestAvg
A missense variant reported as uncertainA child with developmental delay has a heterozygous missense variant classified as a variant of uncertain significance. How would you interpret and explain this result?37871
A family with an affected boyA boy has a confirmed X-linked recessive condition. His mother is an unaffected carrier. Explain the inheritance and recurrence risks to the family.28275
Positive prenatal screening resultA pregnant patient has a high-chance cell-free DNA screening result for trisomy 21. Explain what the result means and discuss next steps.17368
Predictive testing in an adult familyAn asymptomatic adult asks about predictive testing for a familial pathogenic variant associated with an adult-onset condition. How would you approach the request?0——

Station 1: Interpreting a variant of uncertain significance

This station tests whether you can distinguish a laboratory classification from a clinical conclusion. The key point is that a variant of uncertain significance (VUS) is not, by itself, a confirmed explanation for a patient’s features. It is also not the same as a benign result. Explain what evidence would be useful and how you would prevent an uncertain finding from driving an inappropriate decision.

Answer the examiner’s question aloud. In particular, say what you would check about the phenotype, the gene–condition relationship, family testing and the evidence behind the laboratory classification. A strong answer acknowledges uncertainty without stopping at “more information is needed”.

A MySummaries marked oral attempt on this station might look like this:

Oral — A missense variant reported as uncertainMarked

Examiner

A child with developmental delay has a heterozygous missense variant classified as a variant of uncertain significance in a gene associated with an autosomal dominant disorder. How would you interpret and explain this result?

2:363:00 practice targetMark answer
76%A missense variant reported as uncertain — marked76/100 · Developing · 2:36 spoken of 3:00 practice target
Variant classification and evidence15/20

You correctly stated that a VUS is inconclusive, but did not explain that classification uses multiple evidence types and their strength.

ImproveName population frequency, segregation or de novo evidence, phenotype fit, functional data and validated computational evidence as relevant evidence sources.

Clinical correlation and limitations16/20

You asked whether the child’s features fit the associated condition, but did not mention the possibility of an uncertain gene–disease relationship or variable expression.

ImproveCheck the gene–disease validity and the specific phenotype; avoid treating a broad feature such as developmental delay as proof of causation.

Communication and next steps15/20

You avoided calling the result diagnostic, but your follow-up plan was too vague.

ImproveExplain the uncertainty, discuss suitable segregation or other evidence gathering with the genetics team, and state that reinterpretation may be appropriate as evidence changes.

A strong answerI would first confirm the exact variant, transcript, laboratory report and the gene–condition relationship, then check whether the child’s phenotype is consistent with that condition. A VUS is an inconclusive classification: it neither establishes the diagnosis nor excludes it. Classification should be considered using evidence such as population frequency, segregation or confirmed de novo status, phenotype specificity, functional studies and appropriately validated computational evidence, with each item weighted according to its strength. I would explain the uncertainty to the family and avoid using the VUS alone for predictive testing or irreversible clinical decisions. I would discuss whether additional evidence, such as parental testing or expert phenotype review, is appropriate and whether the laboratory or clinical genetics service can review the classification as evidence develops.

That is a MySummaries station, filled with medical genetics material. Yours is written from your own notes. Start free

The model does not claim that every VUS should be tested in relatives or that every case can be resolved. The usefulness of parental or family testing depends on the variant, the condition, the family structure and the laboratory’s interpretation process. In some cases, phenotype review or additional clinical information is more helpful than another test.

A common weak answer is to say “the child has the disorder because the variant is in the gene”. A better answer separates three questions: is the gene associated with the relevant condition; does the child’s phenotype fit; and is the evidence for this particular variant strong enough to support causality? Those questions may have different answers.

Station 2: Explaining X-linked recessive inheritance

This station tests accurate recurrence-risk reasoning and the ability to explain it without implying certainty about a future child’s sex or genotype. State the assumptions behind the calculation: the mother is confirmed to carry the familial variant, and the condition follows the stated X-linked recessive pattern. If those facts are not confirmed, say what you would establish first.

Answer aloud as if speaking to a family, not just reciting a Punnett square. Explain the chance separately for each pregnancy, distinguish an affected son from a carrier daughter, and mention that the family may benefit from discussion with a genetics professional about testing options.

A MySummaries marked attempt on the inheritance station could look like this:

Oral — A family with an affected boyMarked

Examiner

A boy has a confirmed X-linked recessive condition. His mother is an unaffected carrier of the familial variant. Explain the inheritance and recurrence risks to the family.

2:213:00 practice targetMark answer
81%A family with an affected boy — marked81/100 · Sound, with one clarification needed · 2:21 spoken of 3:00 practice target
Inheritance mechanism17/20

You correctly explained that a son receives his X chromosome from his mother, but did not make clear that the father does not pass an X-linked variant to a son.

ImproveState that a son inherits his X chromosome from his mother and his Y chromosome from his father.

Risk calculation17/20

You gave the 50% risk for sons but initially described it as a risk across all pregnancies.

ImproveFor each pregnancy, explain the 50% chance of inheriting the variant from a carrier mother; among sons, the chance of being affected is 50%, assuming the stated condition and variant.

Family-centred explanation15/20

Your explanation was clear but did not offer a route to confirm the familial variant in relatives or discuss uncertainty in the family history.

ImproveOffer discussion of appropriate familial testing and explain that individual choices should be supported by genetics counselling.

A strong answerAssuming the mother is confirmed to carry the familial variant, each pregnancy is an independent event. Each son has a 50% chance of inheriting her X chromosome carrying the variant and, for a typical X-linked recessive condition, being affected; each son has a 50% chance of inheriting her other X chromosome. Each daughter has a 50% chance of inheriting the variant and being a carrier, although the clinical effects of some X-linked conditions in females can vary. The father passes his Y chromosome to sons and his X chromosome to daughters, so he does not pass an X-linked variant to a son. I would offer an opportunity to discuss testing and reproductive or family implications with a genetics service, in line with the family’s circumstances and preferences.

The important correction is the denominator. “A 50% chance in each pregnancy” can be misunderstood as a 50% chance that any child will be affected. More precisely, with a carrier mother, each son has a 50% chance of inheriting the variant; each daughter has a 50% chance of inheriting it. The chance that a pregnancy results in an affected child depends on the sex distribution and the specific condition, so avoid giving a single overall figure unless the question asks for it and you state your assumptions.

Do not automatically describe all carrier daughters as unaffected. Expression can vary between X-linked conditions and between individuals. The station specifies a typical X-linked recessive pattern for calculating risk; real family counselling should address the particular condition and variant.

Station 3: A positive cell-free DNA screening result

This station tests whether you keep screening separate from diagnosis. Cell-free DNA testing analyses placental DNA fragments circulating in maternal blood and estimates the chance of certain chromosomal conditions. A high-chance result for trisomy 21 is not, on its own, a diagnostic result. Explain that distinction plainly, then discuss confirmation and the patient’s choices without pressuring them towards a particular decision.

A MySummaries marked attempt on the screening station could look like this:

Oral — Positive prenatal screening resultMarked

Examiner

A pregnant patient has a high-chance cell-free DNA screening result for trisomy 21. Explain what the result means and discuss next steps.

2:483:00 practice targetMark answer
72%Positive prenatal screening result — marked72/100 · Developing · 2:48 spoken of 3:00 practice target
Screening versus diagnosis14/20

You correctly called the result a screening result, but did not explain that it estimates chance rather than confirming the fetal chromosome status.

ImproveSay directly that a high-chance result is not diagnostic and that confirmation requires discussion of diagnostic testing.

Test limitations and interpretation15/20

You noted that the test is not definitive but omitted that cell-free DNA in maternal blood is predominantly placental in origin.

ImproveExplain that the result reflects placental DNA and can differ from the fetal chromosome result; avoid treating it as a definitive fetal diagnosis.

Communication and next steps14/20

You mentioned invasive testing without first eliciting the patient’s preferences or explaining that the choice is theirs.

ImproveOffer balanced information, discuss diagnostic options with an appropriately qualified prenatal or genetics team, and support an informed choice.

A strong answerI would first ask what the patient has been told and what they would like to understand. Cell-free DNA testing is a screening test: a high-chance result for trisomy 21 estimates an increased chance but does not confirm the fetal chromosome result. The DNA fragments tested are predominantly placental in origin, so a screening result can differ from the fetal result. I would offer timely discussion with the appropriate prenatal or genetics team about diagnostic testing, including the benefits, limitations and risks of the available options in that setting. I would give balanced information, respect the patient’s choices and avoid making decisions on the screening result alone.

The model deliberately does not name a particular diagnostic procedure as the right choice for every patient. The appropriate options and their timing depend on local practice, gestational circumstances and the patient’s preferences. A candidate should know the relevant options for their own setting and verify current guidance from the official service or professional body rather than inventing a local pathway.

A frequent lost mark is to say that the screening test “shows the baby has Down syndrome”. Replace that with “the result indicates a higher chance and needs discussion of diagnostic confirmation”. Another is to move directly to testing without checking what the patient wants to know. A clear explanation of uncertainty is part of accurate genetics communication, not an optional soft skill.

Turn missed marks into another attempt

After each practice station, identify one specific omission. Was it a missing assumption in the recurrence-risk calculation? A failure to distinguish a VUS from a pathogenic classification? Did you name a screening result as diagnostic? Convert that omission into a short question, then answer it again at the next session.

When you review your recording, listen for absolute language: “proves”, “will happen”, or “is normal”. Ask whether the evidence justifies that certainty. Also listen for the action you recommend. “Refer appropriately” is rarely a complete answer unless you state what needs clarification, who can help, and what decision the person is being supported to make.

The transcript view can isolate one phrase that cost marks. In this example, the candidate gives the right broad direction but needs to explain what confirmation means and keep the decision with the patient.

A MySummaries transcript review might highlight the wording this way:

Transcript

I would explain that the result is a higher-chance screening result, not a diagnosis. Then I would arrange the next test. The patient should have time to hear the options and decide what they want. The result proves the fetus has trisomy 21.

not enough detail
Then I would arrange the next test.

This skips the patient’s choice and does not identify that diagnostic testing should be discussed with a qualified prenatal team.

Say: I would offer discussion with the appropriate prenatal or genetics team about diagnostic testing, its limitations and risks, and support the patient to choose whether to proceed.

How MySummaries helps

Build a medical genetics board from your own notes, then practise viva stations generated from those sections. The platform records spoken answers, marks them against practice criteria, and lets you review weak explanations alongside flashcards and examiner-voice audio lectures. Use it to rehearse the topics your course or professional body actually requires, and check official guidance for the format and syllabus you are preparing for. Open MySummaries.