What a respiratory medicine viva is testing

A viva asks you to make your clinical thinking audible. It is not enough to name a diagnosis: you need to explain what you would do first, what information would change your plan, and how you would keep the patient safe. Common respiratory topics include breathlessness, oxygenation, obstructive lung disease, pleural disease, pulmonary embolism and interstitial lung disease.

There is no single international respiratory medicine viva format. The number and length of stations, the examiner’s rubric and the expected local guidelines depend on your course or examining body. Check its official website or handbook for those details. The cases below are practice scenarios, not a claim about a particular exam’s questions or marking scheme.

For each case, use a repeatable sequence: state whether the patient is stable; summarise the key problem; give your immediate assessment and actions; offer a prioritised differential; request focused tests; then explain treatment, escalation and review. Say what you would do while investigations are pending. If you do not know a local threshold or protocol, say so and explain how you would check it rather than guessing.

Set up a focused practice board

Build a board from the material you are expected to know: lecture slides, local guidelines, course notes and your own summaries. Organise it around decisions, not broad chapter titles. For example, a section called “Acute hypercapnic respiratory failure” should show the oxygen target, the blood gas features that prompt non-invasive ventilation (NIV), contraindications or failure signs, and when to seek senior or critical-care support.

Keep locally variable details visible. Oxygen targets, antibiotic choices, anticoagulation pathways and escalation arrangements should be checked against the guidance used in your setting. A board on this topic in MySummaries might look like this:

ExaminerRespiratory medicine examiner
Prioritised assessment and clinical reasoningSafe investigation and treatmentEscalation, communication and review

The examiner strip sets three practice emphases for these respiratory medicine cases; they are not a universal examination rubric.

The board should be short enough to scan before speaking, but precise enough to stop vague answers. A useful core list contains facts that would change a decision: for example, the blood gas pattern that supports acute hypercapnic respiratory failure, pleural-fluid criteria, and the principle of using a validated pre-test probability pathway for suspected pulmonary embolism.

StationAttemptsBestAvg
Acute COPD exacerbationA 68-year-old with COPD is increasingly breathless and drowsy. Talk me through your immediate assessment and management.37871
Unilateral pleural effusionA 59-year-old has fever, pleuritic pain and a new unilateral effusion. How would you investigate and manage it?27469
Suspected pulmonary embolismA 56-year-old has sudden pleuritic chest pain, tachycardia and unilateral leg swelling. What is your approach?0——
Progressive breathlessness and interstitial changeA patient has six months of exertional dyspnoea and bilateral interstitial abnormalities. How would you structure the assessment?16666

These station openers turn board topics into spoken practice; the attempt figures are a sample progress view.

Station 1: acute COPD exacerbation

Start with the threat, not the label. In a breathless or drowsy patient, describe an ABCDE assessment, monitoring, urgent help if needed, and controlled oxygen while you establish oxygenation and obtain a blood gas. State a target saturation of 88–92% for a patient at risk of hypercapnic respiratory failure while awaiting blood gas results, unless an individual plan or local guidance indicates otherwise. Avoid presenting oxygen as a treatment to withhold: the aim is controlled oxygen with reassessment.

The case below gives enough information to identify acute-on-chronic hypercapnic respiratory failure. Your spoken answer should link the blood gas to an action, rather than reciting numbers without interpretation.

Oral — Acute COPD exacerbationMarked

Examiner

A 68-year-old with COPD is drowsy, breathing at 30 breaths per minute and has an oxygen saturation of 82% on room air. The blood gas shows pH 7.28, PaCO₂ 8.1 kPa, PaO₂ 7.0 kPa and bicarbonate 29 mmol/L. Talk me through your assessment and management.

2:323:00Mark answer
78%Acute COPD exacerbation — marked78/100 · Developing · 2:32 spoken of 3:00
Prioritised assessment and recognition of severity8/10

You recognised drowsiness and respiratory acidosis as urgent features.

ImproveState the immediate ABCDE assessment, monitoring and early senior review before moving to the longer-term plan.

Interpretation of investigations8/10

You identified hypercapnia with acidaemia and likely chronic compensation.

ImproveConnect the gas to acute-on-chronic ventilatory failure and say that repeat gases are needed after initial treatment.

Safe initial treatment7/10

You mentioned controlled oxygen and inhaled bronchodilators.

ImproveGive the 88–92% target while awaiting gases, and include systemic corticosteroid treatment and antibiotics when clinically indicated under local guidance.

Escalation and reassessment8/10

You proposed NIV for persistent acidosis and recognised the need to reassess.

ImproveState that NIV is considered when hypercapnic acidosis persists despite optimal initial treatment, and describe what would prompt urgent escalation if it fails.

A strong answerI would assess him using ABCDE, apply monitoring, obtain senior help and treat this as an emergency because he is drowsy and acidotic. I would give controlled oxygen, initially targeting 88–92% while awaiting and repeating blood gases, and use inhaled short-acting bronchodilators. I would give systemic corticosteroids and consider antibiotics if the clinical features support bacterial infection, following local guidance. The gas shows hypercapnia with acidaemia and raised bicarbonate, consistent with acute-on-chronic ventilatory failure; if acidosis persists despite initial optimal treatment, I would arrange NIV and monitor closely. I would reassess his work of breathing, consciousness and gas exchange, and escalate promptly if he deteriorates or NIV is unsuitable or unsuccessful.

That is a MySummaries station, filled with respiratory medicine material. Yours is written from your own notes. Start free

The main improvement is to make the sequence explicit: immediate stabilisation, treatment, then reassessment and escalation. Do not state that every COPD exacerbation requires antibiotics; explain which clinical features would support them and follow local guidance. Similarly, NIV is not a substitute for monitoring or a reason to delay escalation in a patient who is deteriorating.

After the attempt, review whether you named the severity, interpreted the gas, gave a controlled oxygen plan, and described what happens if the patient does not improve. Practise again with a different blood gas or a patient who is not drowsy. The point is to adapt the same structure, not memorise a single speech.

Station 2: unilateral pleural effusion

A good answer separates diagnosis from drainage. First assess stability and likely causes, including infection, malignancy, heart failure and pulmonary embolism. In a new unilateral effusion, thoracic ultrasound helps characterise the fluid and guide a diagnostic aspiration. Explain what you would send: pleural-fluid protein and lactate dehydrogenase (LDH), paired serum protein and LDH, pH and glucose where relevant, microbiology when infection is suspected, and cytology when malignancy is a possibility.

Use Light’s criteria accurately: an effusion is exudative if at least one criterion is met—pleural-fluid to serum protein ratio greater than 0.5, pleural-fluid to serum LDH ratio greater than 0.6, or pleural-fluid LDH greater than two-thirds of the upper limit of normal serum LDH. Interpret results alongside the clinical picture; the criteria classify fluid but do not identify the cause on their own.

Oral — Unilateral pleural effusionMarked

Examiner

A 59-year-old with fever and pleuritic pain has a moderate, free-flowing unilateral pleural effusion on ultrasound. Aspirated fluid is cloudy, with a pH of 7.16. How would you interpret this and what would you do next?

2:483:00Mark answer
74%Unilateral pleural effusion — marked74/100 · Developing · 2:48 spoken of 3:00
Focused differential and clinical assessment8/10

You considered pleural infection and did not assume that the appearance alone proves the cause.

ImproveMention malignancy, pulmonary embolism and other relevant causes while assessing the patient’s stability and history.

Appropriate sampling and interpretation8/10

You requested pleural studies and understood the low pH as concerning in this setting.

ImproveName paired serum and pleural protein and LDH for Light’s criteria, plus microbiology and other tests guided by the differential.

Safe procedural and treatment plan7/10

You proposed drainage and antimicrobial treatment for likely pleural infection.

ImproveSay that drainage decisions follow the full clinical and ultrasound assessment; a pH below 7.2 in suspected pleural infection supports chest-drain drainage if safely accessible, under local guidance.

Review and escalation7/10

You recognised the need to monitor response.

ImproveAdd a plan for review of symptoms, inflammatory response, imaging and drain function, with specialist input if the collection does not resolve.

A strong answerI would assess his stability and treat this as a likely pleural infection, while keeping other causes of a unilateral effusion in mind. I would use ultrasound to assess the collection and guide sampling, sending pleural fluid for pH, glucose, protein, LDH and microbiology, with paired serum protein and LDH for Light’s criteria. A pH of 7.16 in suspected pleural infection supports drainage if the fluid is safely accessible; I would discuss this promptly with the respiratory team and follow local procedure and antibiotic guidance. I would monitor clinical response and drain function, and arrange follow-up imaging and specialist review if he does not improve. I would also consider whether cytology or further investigation is needed if the history or subsequent course raises concern for malignancy.

The key mark here is the link between a result and a decision: a low pleural-fluid pH in suspected infection supports drainage, provided the collection is accessible and the clinical assessment agrees. Do not treat a single laboratory value as a complete management plan. Explain who you would involve, how you would monitor the patient and what you would do if drainage or antibiotics did not produce improvement.

For other effusions, keep the same framework but change the leading differential and tests. A suspected malignant effusion needs appropriate cytology and further investigation if the first sample does not establish the diagnosis. A likely transudate needs assessment and treatment of its systemic cause. Confirm local sampling and drainage protocols before applying them in practice.

Station 3: suspected pulmonary embolism

This station tests whether you use probability to guide investigation rather than ordering tests indiscriminately. First state whether the patient is haemodynamically stable. Take a focused history, examine for alternative diagnoses and features of deep-vein thrombosis, and use a validated pre-test probability pathway used in your setting. The pathway determines whether D-dimer testing or imaging is appropriate; do not quote a threshold unless you know which assay and local pathway apply.

In a stable patient with a high clinical probability, proceed to appropriate imaging according to local guidance. In a patient with lower probability, a D-dimer may help decide whether imaging is needed. If the patient is unstable, escalate urgently; bedside assessment may help guide immediate decisions, and a patient too unstable for transport should not be managed as though they were on a routine imaging pathway. Consider anticoagulation while awaiting imaging when clinical probability and delay justify it and there is no contraindication, following local guidance.

Oral — Suspected pulmonary embolismMarked

Examiner

A 56-year-old develops sudden pleuritic chest pain and breathlessness. His pulse is 118, blood pressure is 124/78 mmHg, oxygen saturation is 91% on room air, and one calf is swollen. What is your approach?

2:263:00Mark answer
80%Suspected pulmonary embolism — marked80/100 · Competent · 2:26 spoken of 3:00
Initial stability assessment and differential8/10

You identified that he is currently normotensive and considered pulmonary embolism as a priority.

ImproveState immediate observations and red flags for deterioration, while briefly considering important alternatives such as pneumothorax and acute coronary syndrome.

Probability-led investigation8/10

You used a clinical probability assessment to organise the diagnostic pathway.

ImproveName the validated local pathway and explain that it determines whether D-dimer or imaging is appropriate.

Treatment and safety8/10

You considered anticoagulation while awaiting imaging and checked for bleeding risk.

ImproveMake the decision conditional on probability, expected delay and contraindications, and follow local guidance.

Escalation and communication8/10

You included escalation if the patient became unstable.

ImproveSay what change would trigger urgent senior review and how you would manage a patient too unstable for routine transfer to imaging.

A strong answerI would assess him immediately for haemodynamic instability, repeat observations and consider other urgent causes of chest pain and hypoxaemia. Pulmonary embolism is a significant possibility given the sudden pleuritic symptoms and swollen calf. I would use the validated clinical probability pathway used locally to decide whether D-dimer testing or imaging is appropriate, and arrange the indicated imaging promptly. If investigation is delayed, I would consider anticoagulation after assessing bleeding risk and following local guidance. I would seek urgent senior input if he deteriorates; an unstable patient needs an emergency pathway rather than routine transfer for imaging.

The strongest answers do not treat D-dimer as a screening test for every breathless patient. They state that pre-test probability determines its role and that imaging choice follows the local pathway. They also make anticoagulation conditional: name the clinical reasoning, check for contraindications and account for the time to imaging. In an unstable patient, shift from routine diagnosis to immediate resuscitation and urgent senior or specialist decision-making.

Review the answer, not just the score

After each attempt, identify one sentence that earned credit and one missing action that could affect safety or the next decision. For example, “I would arrange NIV” is weaker than explaining the gas finding, the initial treatment already given, the need to reassess and the conditions for escalation. Turn the missing point into a short prompt, then answer it aloud in a fresh attempt.

A transcript is useful when an answer sounds fluent but lacks a decision. This one shows a common weakness: an unqualified referral statement does not tell the examiner what the candidate thinks or what they would do next.

Transcript

I would assess the patient and confirm the effusion on ultrasound. I would refer them to respiratory. Then I would consider further tests.

not enough detail
I would refer them to respiratory.

Referral is appropriate, but the answer gives no reason, immediate plan or investigation to discuss.

Say: I would discuss him urgently with the respiratory team because the pleural-fluid pH is 7.16 in suspected infection, and arrange ultrasound-guided drainage if the collection is safely accessible, alongside local antibiotic treatment.

The revised sentence earns its place because it connects the finding to a reasoned action. Use this test on your own recordings: for every “I would investigate”, name the investigation and what it will answer; for every “I would treat”, name the treatment and its purpose; for every “I would refer”, state the urgency and the decision you need help with.

How MySummaries helps

MySummaries turns your own respiratory notes into a board, then uses that board to create recorded viva practice. You can answer a station aloud, review feedback against practice criteria, and turn points you repeatedly miss into revision prompts. Build the board from the guidance and course material relevant to your setting, then open MySummaries to practise from it.