What a taxation viva can test
There is no single international taxation viva format. A university, professional body or employer may assess different topics and use different criteria. Check the relevant syllabus, candidate guidance and prescribed jurisdictions before treating any practice question as representative of your assessment.
For cross-border taxation, the challenge is often not recalling a rule in isolation. It is explaining which domestic law applies, whether a tax treaty changes the result, what facts are missing and what conclusion is justified. The OECD Model Tax Convention is a useful reference point, but it is not itself binding law. The applicable domestic legislation, treaty wording, protocols and current guidance control the actual answer.
A useful response has four moves: identify the issue, state the rule with its limits, apply the facts, then give a qualified conclusion and say what you would check next. Avoid jumping straight to a definite tax outcome when the facts or governing law are incomplete.
For practice, the MySummaries examiner strip can set a general cross-border lens without claiming to reproduce a particular institution’s viva rubric.
Use those emphases as a rehearsal checklist, not as a claim about how a particular examiner will mark you. If your course names a treaty, country pair or tax authority guidance, substitute that material for the general reference points used in these examples.
Turn topic headings into answerable stations
A station is easier to practise when it starts with a concrete problem and an opening question. These four scenarios cover company residence, permanent establishment, transfer pricing and treaty withholding relief. Together, they require you to explain both the likely issue and the limits of what can be concluded from the facts.
In the MySummaries oral tab, a set of stations might be arranged like this:
The figures indicate practice attempts, not exam results. For each station, speak in complete sentences rather than reciting disconnected definitions. If the prompt leaves out information that would affect the answer, identify it expressly and explain why it matters.
Station 1: Company residence
This station tests whether you distinguish incorporation from effective management and domestic residence rules from treaty resolution. A strong answer does not assume that the place of incorporation settles every cross-border residence question.
The MySummaries recording for this station could present the question and feedback this way:
Examiner
A company is incorporated in State A. Its directors live in State B, where they meet and make the major strategic decisions. The company also has staff and premises in State A. How would you analyse its tax residence?
You recognised possible residence in both states rather than treating incorporation as decisive.
ImproveState that each country’s domestic residence test must be checked separately.
You mentioned a treaty tie-breaker but treated the place of effective management as an automatic answer.
ImproveCheck the exact treaty wording. Some treaties use a competent-authority process for a dual-resident company.
You connected the directors’ decision-making location to management, but did not address the company’s operations in State A.
ImproveSeparate evidence of strategic control from evidence relevant to State A’s domestic residence test.
Your conclusion was appropriately cautious, but you did not identify the documents needed to verify where decisions were made.
ImproveAsk for board minutes, delegation records and the applicable domestic rules and treaty.
A strong answerI would first test residence under the domestic law of State A and State B; incorporation may be relevant in State A, but it does not resolve the other country’s test. The directors’ location and where strategic decisions are actually made are relevant facts, and I would verify them against board minutes and delegated-authority records. If both states treat the company as resident, I would then read the applicable treaty’s company tie-breaker rather than assume it uses one universal test. Depending on the wording, the treaty may require the competent authorities to resolve the issue. I would give a final conclusion only after checking the legislation, treaty and facts for the relevant tax period.
That is a MySummaries station, filled with taxation material. Yours is written from your own notes. Start free
Notice the order: domestic tests first, treaty second, evidence throughout. In an actual answer, name the governing countries and tax period if they are supplied. If they are not, say that you cannot choose the relevant treaty or confirm the result yet. Avoid stating that every treaty resolves corporate dual residence using a single place-of-effective-management rule.
A useful follow-up is: “What evidence would you request?” You could mention board minutes, where directors joined meetings, who had authority to make decisions, where decisions were implemented and whether the records reflect what happened in practice. Explain that a registered office or meeting address alone may not establish where substantive decisions were made.
Station 2: Permanent establishment
This scenario tests whether you can distinguish a local business presence from a permanent establishment (PE) under the treaty that actually applies. A subsidiary’s existence does not, by itself, automatically mean its foreign parent has a PE there. Nor does the word “office” settle the question: the facts and treaty definition matter.
The MySummaries practice examiner can probe those distinctions with a focused follow-up:
Examiner
A company resident in State A rents a dedicated office in State B for 18 months. Its employees work there regularly and negotiate customer contracts, but the final signatures are made at head office in State A. What is your analysis?
You identified a fixed-place issue but focused too narrowly on where contracts were signed.
ImproveCheck the treaty’s fixed-place wording and whether the premises are at the enterprise’s disposal.
You used the dedicated office and regular activity, but did not test the duration and nature of the business carried on there.
ImproveExplain what the employees do and whether the activity is covered by a treaty exception.
You treated head-office signature as enough to rule out an agency PE.
ImproveCheck whether employees habitually conclude contracts or play the principal role leading to contracts, where the treaty’s wording makes that relevant.
You avoided a categorical conclusion, but omitted the treaty and local-law checks needed next.
ImproveConclude that the facts raise PE risk, then identify the applicable treaty, exceptions and domestic rules to verify.
A strong answerThe dedicated office and regular use for 18 months raise a fixed-place PE question, but I would check the exact treaty definition and whether the office is at the enterprise’s disposal. I would identify the business activities carried on there and consider whether any specific treaty exception applies; I would not assume that all office activity is preparatory or auxiliary. The place of signature is not necessarily decisive for an agency PE analysis. I would ask whether the employees habitually conclude contracts or, under the applicable wording, play the principal role leading to contracts that are routinely concluded without material modification. On these facts there is a PE risk to investigate, but I would need the treaty text and a fuller account of the employees’ authority and activities before reaching a conclusion.
The answer earns clarity by separating two possible routes: a fixed-place PE and an agency PE. Do not collapse them into “the company has an office, so it has a PE” or “head office signs, so there is no PE”. The treaty’s language matters, including its treatment of contract activity and any exceptions. Domestic rules may also matter, but do not assume they can override a treaty limitation without checking the legal framework.
If the examiner asks what you would investigate next, give facts tied to the tests: who leases and controls the premises, how regularly the office is used, which functions employees perform, their authority in negotiations and how contracts are concluded in practice. That is more useful than asking for “more information” without explaining what information could change the answer.
Station 3: Transfer pricing on a related-party loan
This station checks whether you can explain an arm’s-length analysis without treating a headline interest rate as the whole answer. The stated 8% rate cannot be judged simply by comparing it with a market rate that has not been specified. The loan’s economically relevant terms and the borrower’s circumstances need examination.
A MySummaries oral attempt on this question can show where an answer needs more detail:
Examiner
A parent company lends 10 million to its subsidiary at 8% interest. There is no information about currency, maturity, security or the subsidiary’s credit position. How would you assess the terms?
You correctly identified the need to compare the controlled transaction with conditions independent parties would agree.
ImproveMake clear that the analysis starts by accurately delineating the actual transaction.
You named maturity and security but omitted currency and the borrower’s creditworthiness.
ImproveWork through the loan’s material terms and the parties’ functions, assets and risks.
You suggested market comparisons but did not say how you would assess whether comparables are genuinely comparable.
ImproveDescribe adjustments or other methods only after identifying reliable data and material differences.
You avoided declaring 8% excessive, but did not specify the next evidence to obtain.
ImproveRequest the agreement, repayment capacity analysis, comparable data and applicable local transfer-pricing rules.
A strong answerI would begin by accurately delineating the loan: its amount, currency, term, repayment schedule, security, covenants and the parties’ actual conduct. I would assess the subsidiary’s creditworthiness and realistic borrowing capacity, taking account of relevant group support without assuming it guarantees the debt. I would then identify reliable independent transactions or other evidence, adjusting for material differences such as maturity, currency, security and market conditions. The arm’s-length rate cannot be inferred from the 8% figure alone, and I would not replace it with an unsupported benchmark. I would document the method and evidence under the applicable local transfer-pricing rules and explain any remaining uncertainty.
Keep the analysis in sequence: define the transaction, examine the economically relevant characteristics, identify a suitable method and evidence, then give a conclusion limited to what that evidence supports. Depending on the facts, the inquiry may also include whether independent parties would have entered into a loan on those terms, or whether different financing terms would better describe the transaction. Do not claim that a particular method or rate is correct without the facts and governing rules.
A common weak answer says, “Find a comparable loan and use its rate.” Improve it by saying what would make a comparison useful: currency, term, borrower credit risk, security, seniority, covenants and market conditions. If reliable comparable data are unavailable, explain that limitation instead of inventing a benchmark.
Review the wording, not just the final score
After an oral attempt, listen for places where a short phrase hides a missing step. “The treaty applies” does not identify which treaty or article. “It is arm’s length” does not explain the comparison. “There is no PE because the contract was signed elsewhere” skips other possible tests. Replace such conclusions with the legal question, the relevant facts and the next check.
A transcript review in MySummaries could flag a phrase that needs a more precise explanation:
I would check the relevant treaty and the domestic residence tests. The place of effective management decides the answer. I would review board records and the treaty wording before concluding.
The place of effective management decides the answer.
This makes one possible treaty approach sound universal and skips the treaty’s actual text.
Say: Say: ‘I would check the company tie-breaker in the applicable treaty; its wording may use a competent-authority process or another test.’For your own practice, keep a short error log with three columns: the phrase that lost precision, the missing legal or factual step, and the sentence you will use next time. Re-record the answer after correcting the sentence. The aim is not to memorise a universal script; it is to make your reasoning audible and appropriately qualified.
A repeatable method for new questions
Use this sequence whenever a prompt gives you a cross-border tax problem:
- Define the issue. Is the question about residence, source, a PE, transfer pricing, withholding or another topic?
- Name the governing framework. Identify the relevant domestic law and, where applicable, the exact treaty or other instrument. If the countries are not given, say that you cannot identify the treaty yet.
- State a conditional rule. Give the principle, but qualify it where treaty wording or local legislation can change the result.
- Apply each material fact. Explain what points towards or away from the possible outcome.
- Identify missing evidence. Ask targeted questions and say how the answers could affect the analysis.
- Conclude proportionately. Use “raises a risk”, “is consistent with” or “cannot be determined on these facts” where a definitive answer is not justified.
Practise each topic twice: first with notes available, then with notes closed. In the second attempt, concentrate on the order of reasoning and the precision of your qualifications. Check your course or professional-body materials for the topics and jurisdictions that actually apply to your assessment; use official tax authority publications and the relevant legislation and treaty when verifying a rule.
How MySummaries helps
MySummaries can turn your own taxation notes into revision boards, then use those board sections to generate recorded viva practice, feedback on the spoken answer and review points for another attempt. Add the treaties and jurisdiction-specific materials from your course before practising those questions. Open MySummaries.