How to practise for a classical mechanics viva

A viva tests more than whether you can recall a formula. You need to choose a useful model, state its assumptions, explain the mathematical steps and interpret the result. If you are unsure, say what you know, identify what information is missing and continue from there. A clear partial argument is more useful than a confident answer built on an unstated assumption.

The stations below are practice exercises, not a description of any particular institution's official viva format. The times are practice targets, not exam timings. Check your department or examining body's guidance for the actual format and assessment criteria.

Set up a short practice session like this:

  1. Read the opening question aloud and start answering without preparing a script.
  2. Talk through the model before substituting numbers: define the system, choose coordinates and state assumptions.
  3. When you use an equation, explain what it says physically and what its terms mean.
  4. End by checking units, signs and limiting cases. If you make an error, correct it aloud and explain why.
  5. After the attempt, note one specific gap to practise next time—for example, confusing static friction with its maximum value.

Aim for a compact answer with a clear sequence, rather than a long monologue. The practice feedback shown here uses criteria such as physical reasoning, mathematical setup and interpretation. These are study prompts, not a claim about an official marking scheme.

A practice examiner strip for this subject might look like this:

ExaminerClassical Mechanics examiner
Physical reasoningMathematical setupInterpretation and assumptions

Choose a different topic each session, but revisit a question when you have a specific improvement to make. For example, repeat a force question after practising free-body diagrams, not simply because you remember the previous answer. A station table helps keep that practice varied and makes it visible when a topic has not been attempted.

A station list for a mechanics board could look like this:

StationAttemptsBestAvg
Block on a rough inclineA 2 kg block is at rest on a 30° incline. The coefficient of static friction is 0.40. Can it remain at rest? Draw the forces and justify your conclusion.38072
Mass–spring oscillatorA 0.50 kg mass on a spring of constant 200 N m⁻¹ is pulled 0.10 m from equilibrium and released. Describe its motion and find its maximum speed.27871
Motion in a central potentialFor a particle in V(r) = −k/r with angular momentum L, derive the effective potential and assess the stability of a circular orbit.17676
Work and energyA particle moves under a force that depends on position. Explain when energy conservation is useful and how you would check whether the force is conservative.0——

Station 1: forces on a rough incline

This question tests whether you can separate the force calculation from the conclusion. A common error is to set friction equal to its maximum value as soon as a coefficient is supplied. Static friction instead takes whatever value is needed to prevent slipping, up to a limit.

For the stated block, take axes parallel and perpendicular to the plane. The normal reaction is determined by the perpendicular balance. Then compare the downslope component of weight with the maximum available static friction. State what the comparison tells you, and do not invent a coefficient of kinetic friction if the block moves.

A marked attempt might look like this:

Oral — Block on a rough inclineMarked

Examiner

A 2 kg block is at rest on a 30° incline. The coefficient of static friction is 0.40. Can it remain at rest? Draw the forces and justify your conclusion.

2:363:00Mark answer
80%Block on a rough incline — marked80/100 · Good reasoning; one distinction to sharpen · 2:36 spoken of 3:00
Free-body diagram and force directions20/25

The answer identifies weight, normal reaction and friction, with friction directed up the plane to oppose the tendency to slide down.

ImproveSay explicitly that the friction direction is determined by the impending relative motion.

Resolution of forces20/25

The normal force is correctly obtained as mg cos 30°, about 17.0 N, and the downslope weight component as mg sin 30°, about 9.81 N.

ImproveState the two components before comparing them.

Use of the friction condition18/25

The answer compares 9.81 N with μsN ≈ 6.80 N, but briefly describes friction as if it always equals μsN.

ImproveFor equilibrium, required static friction is 9.81 N; its maximum is only 6.80 N.

Conclusion and limits of the information22/25

The answer correctly concludes that static equilibrium is impossible, and does not claim to know the acceleration after slipping.

ImproveAdd that acceleration after motion starts needs the coefficient of kinetic friction, which was not supplied.

A strong answerChoose axes parallel and perpendicular to the plane, and draw weight vertically down, the normal reaction perpendicular to the plane, and friction up the plane. The normal reaction is N = mg cos 30° ≈ 17.0 N, while the downslope component of weight is mg sin 30° ≈ 9.81 N. The largest possible static friction is μsN ≈ 0.40 × 17.0 = 6.80 N. Since 9.81 N exceeds 6.80 N, the block cannot remain at rest. Its acceleration after it begins to slide cannot be found without the kinetic-friction coefficient.

That is a MySummaries station, filled with classical mechanics material. Yours is written from your own notes. Start free

Notice the difference between the friction required for equilibrium and the maximum static friction. If the required force were less than the maximum, the block could remain at rest, and the actual friction would match the required force—not automatically the maximum. Practise stating this distinction whenever a problem gives a coefficient of static friction.

The feedback is useful only if you turn it into a better next attempt. Here, the correction is not “learn more about friction” in general. It is: name the required friction, compare it with the limiting value, and avoid calculating an acceleration without the needed data.

Station 2: simple harmonic motion

A spring question lets an examiner probe definitions, equations and physical interpretation in one conversation. Begin by stating the ideal model: a mass on a linear spring, with negligible damping, oscillating about equilibrium. The restoring force is proportional to displacement and points towards equilibrium, so Hooke's law gives the equation of motion.

For the given mass and spring constant, calculate angular frequency first. From there, derive the period. To find the maximum speed, use the fact that speed is greatest at equilibrium, or use conservation of energy between the release point and equilibrium. Keep the amplitude and the initial displacement distinct from the angular frequency.

A second marked attempt might look like this:

Oral — Mass–spring oscillatorMarked

Examiner

A 0.50 kg mass on a spring of constant 200 N m⁻¹ is pulled 0.10 m from equilibrium and released. Describe its motion and find its maximum speed.

2:483:00Mark answer
78%Mass–spring oscillator — marked78/100 · Sound calculation; clarify the model · 2:48 spoken of 3:00
Model and assumptions18/25

The answer recognises a restoring spring force but does not state that damping is neglected and the spring is treated as linear.

ImproveName the ideal simple-harmonic-oscillator assumptions before applying the standard solution.

Equation of motion and frequency21/25

It correctly uses ω = √(k/m) = √(200/0.50) = 20 rad s⁻¹.

ImproveConnect this to ẍ + ω²x = 0 so the origin of the frequency relation is clear.

Speed and energy reasoning20/25

The maximum speed is correctly found as ωA = 2.0 m s⁻¹, but the location of that maximum is not explained.

ImproveState that the speed is greatest at equilibrium, where spring potential energy is least and kinetic energy greatest.

Interpretation and units19/25

The period is correctly given as 0.314 s, with units, but the answer does not describe the phase of the motion at release.

ImproveExplain that release from rest at maximum displacement starts the motion at a turning point.

A strong answerFor an ideal undamped spring, the force is F = −kx, so Newton's second law gives ẍ + (k/m)x = 0. Thus ω = √(k/m) = √(200/0.50) = 20 rad s⁻¹, and the period is T = 2π/ω ≈ 0.314 s. The release point is a turning point, so the amplitude is A = 0.10 m and the initial speed is zero. At equilibrium the speed is greatest; energy conservation gives ½kA² = ½mvmax², hence vmax = ωA = 2.0 m s⁻¹. This result assumes the spring remains linear and damping is negligible.

If asked to defend the result, check it in a second way. The energy at release is ½kA² = 1.0 J. At equilibrium the spring's displacement is zero, so in this ideal model that energy is kinetic: ½mv² = 1.0 J, giving v = 2.0 m s⁻¹. Matching the result from the frequency method is a useful check against an algebra or unit error.

Then test the boundaries of the model. If damping is introduced, the amplitude decreases with time; the undamped result no longer describes the full motion. If the spring does not obey a linear force law over the displacement, the simple harmonic solution also needs reconsideration. You do not need to add complications unprompted, but you should be able to say which assumptions support your answer.

Station 3: a central potential

For a central-force question, make the symmetry do useful work. A force directed along the radius has zero torque about the centre, so angular momentum is conserved. That conservation lets you reduce the radial motion to a one-dimensional problem with an effective potential.

For V(r) = −k/r, where k is positive, the effective potential for a particle of mass m and angular momentum L is Veff(r) = L²/(2mr²) − k/r. A circular orbit occurs at a stationary point of this potential. Stability depends on the curvature there: a local minimum corresponds to stable small radial perturbations.

A third attempt might look like this:

Oral — Motion in a central potentialMarked

Examiner

For a particle in V(r) = −k/r with angular momentum L, derive the effective potential and assess the stability of a circular orbit.

2:523:00Mark answer
76%Motion in a central potential — marked76/100 · Correct structure; show the stability test · 2:52 spoken of 3:00
Use of central-force symmetry20/25

The answer correctly notes that torque about the centre is zero and angular momentum is conserved.

ImproveLink the zero torque directly to constant L, rather than simply asserting conservation.

Effective-potential derivation19/25

It gives Veff = L²/(2mr²) − k/r, but does not explain that the first term is the angular part of the kinetic energy.

ImproveWrite the radial energy as ½m ṙ² + Veff(r) and identify the centrifugal term.

Circular orbit condition19/25

The stationary-point condition is set up correctly, yielding rc = L²/(mk).

ImproveShow the derivative equation and the positive-radius solution explicitly.

Stability and interpretation18/25

The answer says the orbit is stable but does not evaluate the second derivative at rc.

ImproveShow Veff''(rc) = k/rc³ > 0, so the stationary point is a local minimum.

A strong answerA central force has zero torque about its centre, so angular momentum L is conserved. Separating the radial kinetic energy from the angular kinetic energy gives E = ½m ṙ² + L²/(2mr²) − k/r, so Veff(r) = L²/(2mr²) − k/r. A circular orbit is a stationary radius: dVeff/dr = −L²/(mr³) + k/r² = 0, giving rc = L²/(mk). At that radius, d²Veff/dr² = 3L²/(mr⁴) − 2k/r³ = k/r³ > 0. The effective potential therefore has a local minimum, so small radial perturbations about the circular orbit are stable in this ideal model.

A frequent weak answer stops after finding the circular radius. That establishes a stationary orbit, but it does not establish stability. Add the second-derivative test, then explain what its sign means. In this case, the positive curvature means a small displacement changes the effective potential in a way that produces a restoring tendency in the radial motion.

If you are asked about assumptions, distinguish the mathematical potential from a specific physical system. The result follows for the stated attractive inverse-radius potential and conserved angular momentum; it does not automatically describe every central force. Also check signs carefully: the attractive potential is negative, while the angular-momentum term in the effective potential is positive.

Review an answer for missing marks

The wording review below isolates a phrase that sounds plausible but is too compressed to show the reasoning. Practise replacing vague conclusions with the calculation or condition that supports them. The goal is not to memorise a perfect paragraph; it is to notice where an examiner would need you to make a step explicit.

A wording review from the incline station could look like this:

Transcript

The downslope component is mg sin 30°, about 9.81 N, and the normal reaction is about 17.0 N. The friction is μN, so it is about 6.80 N. That is less than the downslope component, so the block slides; I cannot find its acceleration without kinetic friction.

knowledge gap
The friction is μN

This treats static friction as though it always equals its maximum value. The coefficient gives the maximum available static friction, not necessarily the friction acting on a body at rest.

Say: Say: 'The friction required for equilibrium would be 9.81 N. The maximum static friction is μsN = 6.80 N, so equilibrium is impossible.'

Read the revised wording aloud and then try the same distinction in a new setting. For example, explain what happens to friction if the incline angle is reduced until the downslope component is below the limiting value. The answer should make clear that static friction then takes the value needed for equilibrium, provided that value does not exceed its maximum.

A practical routine for your next session

Use a 25-minute session to turn these stations into repeatable practice. Spend two minutes selecting one question and recalling the relevant definitions. Give a three-minute spoken attempt, then take four minutes to check the equations, units and assumptions against your notes. Use five minutes to repair one specific gap, then answer again in no more than three minutes. Finish by writing one short prompt for a later session, such as “derive the effective potential and test the curvature”, rather than copying out a full model answer.

Over the next few sessions, rotate between a force problem, an energy problem, an oscillation and a central-force problem. Vary the numbers or conditions when you can, so you have to reason rather than reproduce a remembered result. Ask a study partner to interrupt with “why?”, “what assumption did you make?” or “how would you check that?” If practising alone, record your answer and listen for unexplained jumps, undefined symbols and conclusions without a supporting calculation.

For each attempt, keep a short error log with three entries: the exact point where the reasoning weakened, the corrected statement, and a new question that would test the same idea. Examples include “used maximum static friction as the actual force”, “gave the oscillator's speed without identifying the equilibrium point”, and “found the circular orbit but did not test stability”. Revisit the question after a gap and see whether you can produce the correction without reading it first.

How MySummaries helps

Build a revision board from your own mechanics notes, then use it to generate spoken viva practice and examiner-style feedback tied to those materials. You can review the marked response, identify a missing step and practise it again. Start at MySummaries.